In what could have been termed as the saddest day of one of the country’s thriving and iconic business leaders, the Chairman of Ceylinco Consolidated Deshamanya Dr. Lalith Kotelawala yesterday pleaded with thousands of deposit holders of the Golden Key Credit Card Company to give him time to sort out the company’s present liquidity crisis: and inability to settle its many depositors in full. Dr. Kotelawala addressed a packed Committee Room B of the BMICH with the entire directorate of Ceylinco Consolidated in attendance. Depositors of every hue had gathered here: these ranged from housewives to engineers, pilots, business professionals and even former members of parliament of Sri Lanka.
Chairman listens to Depositors’ Tales
At the beginning of the meeting, the depositors of Golden Key were given the opportunity to address the Chairman. Many presented their stories and pleaded with Dr. Kotelawala to provide immediate relief for them. “I have deposited my life-long earnings in your company, trusting you and your company. Next month my daughter is getting married and I went to withdraw money but I was turned away. Now I am in a great difficulty in paying off my daughter’s hotel bill. Please help us!” said one depositor. Another lady depositor addressed the Chairman, saying “We have deposited all our money in your company.
We were depending on the interest income for our children’s education. Now all of a sudden, we have found out that our money is lost and our children’s education is in danger. We trust you and you can keep our money but pay our interest accordingly”. “We know how hard you worked to bring up Ceylinco, and we have invested based on you. We have kept our trust in you, please do something.” another depositor stated.
After hearing these stories, Dr. Kotelawala as the Chairman of Ceylinco Consolidated which owns Golden Key addressed the gathering saying “Today I came here with a great pain in mind to address you over what has happened. Let me assure you that I will not run away from this crisis and I will look after you,” Dr. Kotelawala said.
Referring to his letter dated December 3rd which was circulated amongst deposit holders, Dr. Kotelawala said that he would like to remind all depositors of his request for two months to settle all outstanding monies. “Khavan [Perera, Chief Executive Director of Golden Key, now resigned] told me that we are not breaking the law by taking deposits from people but I found later that all the accounts and the audits were wrong and I informed the CID. Now they are conducting an investigation. I am not confident of the data base that we have in the company. It cannot be trusted. That is why we have given you a new form for you to fill in order for us to get your correct information.” Former Member of Parliament Somaweera Chadrasiri, a depositor, then objected to Dr. Kotelawala’s statement by asking “How did a Director Board that was conducting monthly meetings looking after every detail and activities of the company failed to understand there is a fraud is going on?” “We trust you Dr. Kotelawala and have deposited our money trusting you and not any other director of the Board. This is not a beetle shop that we deposited our money and don’t tell us that that data is wrong.” he countered.
The Numbers
Commenting on the latest and the largest Credit Card fraud that has happened in Sri Lanka, a senior employee of Golden Key who wanted to remain anonymous said that the total deposit base portfolio of the company was valued at about Rs.26 billion as of November 26th 2008, though the Balance Sheet of the Golden Key Credit Card Co. Ltd only reflects Rs.5 billion as assets up to now. (The total net disposable assets of the Ceylinco Group is said very recently to be Rs 20 billion, by comparison.) He also informed the Financial Times that there are approximately 10,000 depositors in the company.
In his opinion, he stressed that the financial difficulties of the company had been going on for months while the issue was uplifted with the impact of the Sakvithi Scam as the depositors started to withdraw money also from Golden Key Credit Card Co. Ltd. After monitoring this, on December 18th Dr. Kotelawala requested an audit from Deputy Chairman of Golden Key Group of Ceylinco, Khavan Perera. According to the source, “Followed by the results of the audit on Friday December 19th, Mr. Khavan Perera was asked to resign by Dr. Kotelawala.” Some ascribed this as a political move taken by Dr. Kotelawala to protect his image. Moreover, the source pointed out that while Dr. Kotelawala had publicly raised questions on the integrity and availability of the customer data base and had stated that there were credit cards that had been issued without a record, the source countered that there was no such widespread damage to the database and that the information was by and large in order.
Responding to a question raised by the Daily Mirror Financial Times, the source also said that an internal transaction between Ceylinco Insurance PLC and the Golden Key Group had then taken place on December 18th or 19th to purchase the Golden Key ENT Hospital to facilitate the refund to depositors. On Monday December 22nd, the Dr. Kotelawala had assured and guaranteed employment of the staff of Golden Key Credit Card Co. Ltd. but later he had denied this, according to our sources. The source also said that there were lots of instances in which the Ceylinco subsidiaries have been pumping money to refund the depositors interest and funds. “On December 1st or 2nd Seylan Bank PLC granted Rs. 400 million to finance the refunds. The cash disappeared within a day since we used that money to pay customers’ withdrawals” he added stating that none of the employees of Golden Key was involved in the fraud. Also on December 3rd Dr. Kotelawala sent a letter to all customers of Golden Key assuring that customers should not be worried since the interest payments will be settled within a month. The source also said that the interest bill paid by Golden Key to its customers for October 2008 was approximately Rs. 500 million.
In the wake of these ongoing developments, some shop owners in popular shopping malls in Colombo and suburbs have removed the familiar Golden Key Credit Card “Accepted Here” insignia from their doors.
Golden Key Credit Card Company statement
GKCCCL yesterday informed the general public that today’s scheduled meeting has been cancelled.
“A meeting of the customers of the Colombo Branches was held on 23rd December 2008 as scheduled. A large number of customers attended this meeting. Matters were discussed in detail. A decision was arrived to pay the card holders a payment on account. A detailed repayment plan will be forwarded to the customers as soon as possible. In lieu of the above decision the meeting scheduled for 24th of December 2008 is cancelled,” the Company said.
Meanwhile the company also said that it was decided to pay all the small depositors fast as possible and others to pay after going through audited accounts. The reason is that at a discussion there were many requests from the depositors where some wanted their monies deposited as others wanted only the interest. So we are hoping to talk to all the depositors in order to arrange prepayment,” an official told Daily FT.
Kotelawala still heads the public
quoted subsidiaries
Ceylinco Consolidated is Sri Lanka's largest and most diversified conglomerate, operating nearly 14 subsidiary groups including hundreds of companies under its umbrella. The Founder Chairman, Deshamanya Dr. Lalith Kotelawala continues to be the Chairman of public quoted subsidiaries of Ceylinco Group. He had appointed Deputy Chairpersons as his successors on his 70th Birthday on August 29th 2008 to head other subsidiaries of the Ceylinco Consolidated. Golden Key Group is another subsidiary of Ceylinco Consolidated has approximately 35 companies operating under its arm. Golden Key Credit Co. Ltd. was the first company to introduce credit cards to Sri Lanka and it isone of the oldest companies in the Group.
http://www.dailymirror.lk/December 24, 2008